five.tv Register | Sign in
 
 

Porsche 911November 2009

Highly recommended.

The latest version of Porsche's rear-engined sportscar is better to drive than ever.

Our rating:

5
Porsche 911
 
 

Fifth Gear Porsche 911 review

 
 

1) Brilliant handling.
2) Stunning performance.
3) Reasonably practical for this sort of car, too.

WE DON'T LIKE

1) Expensive options.
2) Confusing range - too many variants.
3) All cost a small fortune to run, with more powerful versions costing a large fortune.

 
 

The Porsche 911 remains one of the great automotive anachronisms: a sportscar with its engine in the wrong place. Yet over the decades, and throughout successive generations, engineers have managed to tame the inherent instability brought on by the rear-mounted engine, creating one of the greatest driver's cars on the market.

The current generation keeps up the evolutionary styling theme of its predecessors, with spectators being left in no doubt about the car's lineage. Details like the circular headlamps and particularly finely hewn rear flanks work well, and give even the standard 911 a real air of class. For 2009, the model has been updated with relatively extravagant features including LED daytime running lights, making a 911 immediately obvious on the road

One of the most impressive technical changes is Porsche's double-clutch PDK automatic gearbox, but it's a shame that the unconventional paddle-shifters (push down for up and up for down) makes controlling gearshifts a pain.

But the cabin is well finished and features far higher quality materials than the slightly plasticky interior of the previous generation. Accommodation is still tight, although the 911 can take two large adults in comfort. The rear seats are barely worthy of the description, though - and getting luggage in and out of the front boot remains a slightly awkward process.

Any niggles about practicality soon fade once on the move: this 911 drives better than any of its predecessors. The perfectly weighted steering gives brilliant feel, grip levels are towering and, as the limits approach, the 911 remains predictable. You really couldn't buy a better handling car for even twice the Porsche's (admittedly hefty) pricetag.

As always with the 911, there is a bewildering number of variants for buyers to choose between. Even the two-wheel drive entry-level 3.6 Carrera enjoys very strong performance, while at the other end of the range the stripped-out GT3 and rocketship Turbo variants are genuine supercars.

The latest Turbo gets a larger than ever flat-six engine, with a 3.8-litre capacity (up from 3.6) - an overhaul significant enough for Porsche to describe it as an all-new engine. It's fair comment since it's based on a different block from the last engine and has an integrated oil sump.

This engine is more powerful too, with a whopping 493bhp delivered at 6,000rpm (compared to 474bhp before), and drinks less fuel so pumps out fewer CO2 emissions.

Zero to 62mph takes 3.4sec, 0-to-100mph is dismissed in 7 seconds and there's a 193mph top speed. That's something special. With launch control engaged on the start-finish straight of the Estoril circuit, we blitzed from standstill to over 120mph in 11 seconds dead. Stand and watch a 911 Turbo accelerate that ferociously and you can almost see the hole in the air it punches. It seems to bend physics.

In all, any 911 would be a consumate performance car that blends driving pleasure with reliability and practicality.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

Not the most original piece of design - it's hard to tell this 911 from the previous generation at first glance. But handsome and well detailed.

HANDLING

A rear mounted engine should be a recipe for dynamic catastrophe, yet Porsche has made the 911 handle brilliantly.

COMFORT

The ride is firm and can get joggly over rougher surfaces, but high-speed cruising manners are exemplary and the driving position is brilliant.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

Solidly constructed, and with far higher-quality feeling materials in the cabin than before.

PERFORMANCE

Even the most basic version is massively quick - the GT3 and Turbo variants are amongst the fastest cars on the planet.

ROOMINESS

Front seat occupants enjoy reasonable space, but the rear seats are barely up to moving small children short distances, and the small front boot is awkward to access.

STEREO / SAT NAV

The audio system delivers clean, crisp sound to both front seat occupants. Optional satnav system works well.

RUNNING COSTS

You'll need a very healthy bank account to even contemplate putting a 911 on the driveway but healthy residual values mean it costs considerably less to own than supercar rivals.

VALUE FOR MONEY

Basic versions have reasonable equipment, but the options list is deep and expensive. It's alarmingly easy to watch the price spiral out of control.

ENVIRONMENT

Definitely not great, although the basic 3.6 litre version's 266 g/km CO2 figure is much better than the horrendous emissions produced by some supercars.

This review has been tagged with: Porsche | porsche 911

There are 17 variants of the 911

911 variants Price (£) Fuel type Engine
size (cc)
CO2 emission
(g/km)
Carrera 3.6 £61,744 Super Unleaded 3614 225
Carrera 4 3.6 £66,011 Super Unleaded 3614 237
Carrera S 3.8 £68,878 Super Unleaded 3800 242
Carrera 3.6 Cabriolet £68,878 Super Unleaded 3614 233
Targa 4 £71,443 Super Unleaded 3614 237
Carrera 4S 3.8 £73,146 Super Unleaded 3800 247
Carrera 4 3.6 Cabriolet £73,146 Super Unleaded 3614 242
Carrera S 3.8 Cabriolet £76,013 Super Unleaded 3800 242
Targa 4S £78,578 Super Unleaded 3800 247
Carrera 4S 3.8 Cabriolet £80,281 Super Unleaded 3800 251
GT3 £81,914 Super Unleaded 3797 298
Turbo £101,823 Super Unleaded 3797 272
GT3 RS £104,841 Super Unleaded 3797 314
Turbo Cabriolet £109,048 Super Unleaded 3797 275
Turbo S £123,263 Super Unleaded 3800
GT2 £128,307 Super Unleaded 3600 298
Turbo S Cabriolet £130,791 Super Unleaded 3800
 
 
 

User reviews (1)

Leave a review

This review is awaiting moderation.

Join FiveFWD

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of FiveFWD:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave comments on articles without signing in
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all