five.tv Register | Sign in
 
 

Renault ScenicJuly 2009

Recommended.

Spacious MPV is better to drive and well priced, but not as user-friendly as some rivals.

Our rating:

4
Renault Scenic
 
 

Fifth Gear Renault Scenic review

 
 

WE DON'T LIKE

 
 

The latest Scenic is a major part of Renault's effort to re-establish itself as the MPV market leader. This practical, family-friendly five-seater is meant to be a little sexier and better to drive than the previous model ? and it's also well priced, undercutting the old Scenic by £2,000, on average model for model.

To maximise the Scenic's appeal, Renault is offering a wide range of powertrains and trims to choose between. Petrol engines include a 108bhp 1.6-litre unit; a more modern 128bhp 1.4-litre turbo; and a range-topping 141bhp 2.0-litre that comes with a CVT automatic gearbox. Most buyers are expected to choose the diesel alternatives, however, which include a frugal 1.5-litre with 85bhp or 105bhp; a 1.9-litre with 128bhp; or a 147bhp 2.0-litre available either as an automatic or manual.

Generally speaking, any Scenic should prove cheap to run, offering value-for-money motoring combined with practicality. That said, the Scenic doesn't deliver as on the latter characteristic as emphatically as we'd like. Its larger dimensions make it very spacious inside, but the rear seats don't fold flat to maximise load space and, although they can be removed, their bulk makes this a tricky process. Big shopping sessions at Ikea are out.

Renault's reliability record is also a worry: the French brand is still at the wrong end of the league table in recent JD Power customer satisfaction surveys.

Those drawbacks aside, though, the Scenic certainly drives in a more sure-footed manner than its predecessor and is impressive on the road compared to many of its MPV rivals. High levels of refinement, including a pleasingly muted cabin, help make long trips that bit more bearable.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

Renault has made an effort to make the latest Scenic appear more dynamic than the old model. It's certainly a tidy-looking car, but we'd stop short of saying it was particularly appealing.

HANDLING

Something of a surprise, this: Renault has managed to dial out most of the Scenic's body roll, so it now corners more adeptly than most MPVs. It's also very safe and neutral, behaving predictably if you enter a corner too quickly, with standard-fit ESP quick to intervene if necessary.

COMFORT

The basics are there: plenty of cubbyholes, decent knee and headroom inside, and extra equipment such as Bluetooth on higher end models makes life easier. The ride is a bit suspect on rutted roads, but noise levels are kept impressively low in the cabin.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

This area is a bit of a mixed bag. While some of the materials in the Scenic are of a very high quality, elsewhere there are examples of flimsiness. Renault's reputation for reliability is what causes concern though, even if the company argues it has invested serious sums to improve this.

PERFORMANCE

The 1.4-litre turbo has some pleasing zest to it, but none of the engines offer massive urge. The most popular engine is expected to be the 1.5-litre diesel, which manages 0-62mph in 12.3 seconds, but the 1.9-litre diesel has a more impressive turn of pace while retaining some frugality.

ROOMINESS

There's lots of room in the cabin of the Scenic and cleverly positioned cubbyholes. It's just a shame that Renault hasn't fitted fold-flat seats.

STEREO / SAT NAV

A TomTom version of the Scenic with an integrated satellite navigation unit is available: it's not as clever as some systems, but it?s useful nonetheless. Equipment such as MP3 connectivity comes as standard, while a Bluetooth phone connection is an option.

RUNNING COSTS

Provided there are no mechanical issues, a Scenic is likely to prove very reasonable to run. All engines are frugal and the resulting low CO2 emissions put the Scenic in low road and company car tax bands.

VALUE FOR MONEY

There are generous equipment levels, even on the entry-level Extreme model, which comes with air conditioning, an MP3 connection and electric windows. If you can afford it, upgrade two tiers to Dynamique, where alloy wheels, cruise control, Bluetooth, leather and parking sensors come as standard.

ENVIRONMENT

All of the engines on offer with the Scenic are impressively economical and CO2 emissions are very competitive, ranging from 130g/km to 180g/km. Considering this car can transport a whole family and their kit in comfort, it is an impressively green proposition.

This review has been tagged with: renault | Renault Scenic

There are 13 variants of the Scenic

Scenic variants Price (£) Fuel type Engine
size (cc)
CO2 emission
(g/km)
Dynamique TomTom 1.6 VVT £17,404 Unleaded 1598 174
Dynamique TomTom 1.4 TCe 130 £18,426 Unleaded 1397 168
Dynamique TomTom 1.5 dCi 106 £18,938 Diesel 1461 134
Dynamique TomTom 2.0 140 CVT £19,447 Unleaded 1997
Privilege TomTom 1.4 TCe 130 £19,652 Unleaded 1397 168
Dynamique TomTom 1.9 dCi 130 £20,062 Diesel 1870 145
Privilege TomTom 1.5 dCi 106 £20,164 Diesel 1461 134
Privilege TomTom 2.0 140 CVT £20,674 Unleaded 1997
Privilege TomTom 1.9 dCi 130 £21,288 Diesel 1870 145
Dynamique TomTom 2.0 dCi 160 FAP £21,389 Diesel 1995 173
Dynamique TomTom 2.0 dCi 150 Auto FAP £22,411 Diesel 1995 184
Privilege TomTom 2.0 dCi 160 FAP £22,615 Diesel 1995 173
Privilege TomTom 2.0 dCi 150 Auto FAP £23,637 Diesel 1995 184
 

User reviews

Be the first one to leave a review.

Join FiveFWD

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of FiveFWD:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave comments on articles without signing in
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all